Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Experience: A Perpetuating Myth

The premise that you can only do what you have done in the past and that if you’ve done it in the past then you must be good at it; is still an indispensable staple for the majority of jobs.

Unsurprisingly, we believe vehemently that experience counts; but evidence does not support their view*. Did you know:

• Experienced managers tend to be no more effective than managers with little experience.

• In even the most complex jobs, real learning typically ends after about two years. Too often, 20 years of experience is nothing more than one year of experience repeated 20 times!

• A situation in which experience is obtained is rarely comparable to a new situation.

• Experience is often confused with expertise. Practice makes permanent, not perfect.

Common beliefs to reevaluate are:
• The length of time on a job is a measure of experience,
• Applicants are skilled because they have experience, and
• Professionals who are experienced are good at what they do.

After all, inexperienced candidates have their advantages too.

* Robbins, Stephen P. (2005). Organizational behavior. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Prentice Hall.

No comments: